Assisted Suicide Not Legal in Montana Despite Media’s Claims | LifeNews

No, physician-assisted suicide is not legal in Montana: Its a recipe for abuse and more | The Montana Lawyer

    State Senator Jim Shockley and Margaret Dor at the Montana Lawyer at p. 8 (Nov. 2011): Attorneys Greg Jackson and Matt Bowman provide this analysis: If the idea of suicide itself is suggested to the patient first by the doctor or even by the family, instead of being on the patient’s sole initiative, the situation exceeds “aid in dying” as conceived by the Court. If a particular suicide decision process is anything but “private, civil, and compassionate,” . . . , the Court’s decision wouldn’t guarantee a consent defense. If the patient is less than “conscious,” is unable to “vocalize” his decision, or gets help because he is unable to “self-administer,” or the drug fails and someone helps complete the killing, Baxter would not apply. No doctor can prevent these human contingencies from occurring in a given case . . . in order to make sure that he can later use the consent defense if he is charged with murder. (Analysis of Implications of the Baxter Case on Potential Criminal Liability, Spring 2010, at www.montanansagainstassistedsuicide.org/p/baxter-case-analysis.html)


  • Posted: 11/17/2011
  • |
  • Category: ADF in the News

  • Tags: , , , , , ,

Barbara Coombs Lee: “How Montana Is Revolutionizing the Movement For End-of-Life Choice”

Law Review: The Montana Supreme Court Legalizes Assisted Suicide

Montana Pro-Life Group Says Baxter Supreme Court Decision Didn’t Legalize Assisted Suicide

Group questions legality of physician assisted suicide

Analysis Reveals The Truth About The Baxter Decision On Physician Assisted Suicide

“Peaceful and private” – Montana’s Supreme Court rules on assisted suicide

Death with Stupidity: The Tortured Reasoning of Montana’s High Court

Montana Supreme Court rules “assisted suicide” legal

Pro-life advocates: Montana “assisted suicide” decision could have been worse

Montana Supreme Court upholds “physician-aided suicide”

Montana Supreme Court makes state third to allow unlimited “assisted suicide”

Court: Mont. law allows “doctor-assisted suicide”